How can online discussions be used as a springboard for high level conversations among students in your class? One key is providing good prompts for discussion. Drs. Christine Harrington and Maya Aloni led an inspiring session on “Promoting Critical Thinking through Online Discussion: Developing Questions and Managing Conversations” at a Lilly Conference on College and University Teaching. The session focused on developing prompts that encourage students to demonstrate critical thinking; participants discussed a variety of ways to improve discussion quality. Download the handout for Critical thinking in online discussion (PDF) and explore other resources at Dr. Harrington’s site.
Good prompts for online discussions
Before students can demonstrate critical thinking, they must have the necessary background knowledge, which should be drawn on to craft a post. The question prompt should:
- require that students use their background knowledge
- be open-ended
- stimulate discussion
- allow for multiple student perspectives and
- be directly related to the course learning objectives.
See the PDF for a rubric for writing discussion questions and some good examples.
Here’s an example of a discussion post prompt before implementing the guidelines:
In the readings for this week, several views on homeopathic medicine were discussed. Which one appeals to you and why?
Writing prompt revised using the guidelines:
One of the assigned readings described Dr. Smith’s view of homeopathic medicine. Write a brief rebuttal to Dr. Smith’s position from the point of view of one of the other writers (Jones, Kradau or Kisiniski). Explain the different views to a reader unfamiliar with homeopathy, including references to specific statements by each author.
Other tips in response to common challenges with online discussions:
- give students guidelines for creating good discussion posts (see sample guidelines in PDF)
- instructors should participate moderately in the discussions (not too little, not too much)
- instructors can further discussion by using Socratic questions (see PDF for examples)
- give students credit for posts (see grading, below)
Grading discussion posts
There are at least two methods to facilitate grading online discussions. One is to create a clear, detailed rubric for student posts, and share it with students before using it to grade the student contributions. Another method also uses a rubric, distributed to the students, who are then required to submit their own self-graded portfolio of their best work, following a template provided by the instructor.
Advantages of online discussions
Although there are many advantages of face-to-face conversations, including the instant feedback on ideas and sense of community that can emerge, there are some advantages to moving discussions online:
- Participants have time to reflect and improve the quality of their contributions when writing online
- Introverts are more comfortable participating
- A sense of classroom community is preserved online (rather than forgotten until the next meeting)
- Participation can be required, so there is no social loafing
- Students can access and use outside resources
- Writing helps learning
- Writing is less intimidating than participating in a class-wide discussion
- Student responses can be tracked and credited
- Discussion can take place without a time limit
- Critical thinking can be encouraged by requiring that students support statements they make online
- Student responses can be assessed over time
- Students may not read feedback on written assignments if there is no feedback loop
- Receiving multiple sources of feedback on work resembles professional contexts
For help setting discussion forums in Sakai at Duke, visit the Sakai support site.
Andrea helps faculty use technology effectively and efficiently in their teaching. She works primarily with scientists, using her biology background, love of science and teaching experience. Her current enthusiasms include online science education, active learning (especially team-based learning) and assessment.
- MOOC completion and course activities
- Bass Online Apprentices Share the MOOC Student Experience
- Lessons from a Meta-MOOC
- Embed VoiceThreads into WordPress Sites
- Students in Duke’s Data Analysis and Statistical Inference MOOC
- Marine Megafauna: By the Numbers
- Marine Megafauna MOOC and the Public Library of Science (PLoS) collection